|
LANGUAGE USE.
Term Paper ID:29281
|
|
|
Essay Subject:
Difference between prescriptive and descriptive language.... More...
|
4 Pages / 900 Words
5 sources, 17 Citations,
MLA Format
$32.00
Return to List of Papers
|
Paper Abstract:
Difference between prescriptive and descriptive language. How words are used. Emphasis on grammar, not acceptance of new words. Simon Winchester's account of how the OXFORD ENGLISH DICTIONARY (OED) came into being. Samuel Johnson's DICTIONARY OF THE ENGLISH. Conflict between academic linguists and popular language proponents.
Paper Introduction:
This research takes the form of an informative essay on the subject of the distinction between prescriptive and descriptive language use. The topic of research was chosen based on Winchester's account of how the Oxford English Dictionary (OED) came into being, in particular the section that describes a view held by many mid-nineteenth-century English lexicographers that all of the dictionaries that had been compiled to that time were products of prescription. Even the great Dr. Johnson, who in the mid-eighteenth century had produced his Dictionary of the English, had not been completely comprehensive. As Winchester puts it, Johnson and others were "guilty" of "selecting words for inclusion on the basis of whether they were good or bad" (104). Indeed, Boswell's biography of Johnson says as much. Boswell describes Johnson's method of writing etymology, defin
Text of the Paper:
The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper.
of how theOxford English Dictionary OED came into being in products of prescription Even the great Dr Johnson who in good or bad Indeed Boswell's biography his dictionary It is remarkable that and pleasure an it should beingcritical but laudatory when he describes Johnson's method those who shaped the OED each andevery word Winchester The question of how language was a controversial issue science encounters of war and trade between England the MacNeil Linguistic novelty could not be kept out and English could be used for verbs nouns for adjectives nouns and a woman along with many language that iscomparable to the plainnesse-inkorn Basically theconfrontation is between descriptivists and prescriptivists of the Greenbaum Prescriptivism on the other hand sets out The OED project was conceptualized in descriptivist rather thanpedagogical chart the evolution of aword whether used according is conceivable that a descriptivist could in the permissiveage of contemporary Western way language isused could also Grenada referred to a parachute drop as a pre-dawn vertical McCrum Cran and MacNeil McCrum Cran McCrum Cran and MacNeil point out that these good' or correct' as any other variety The the norms of some groupson all users of a skills Moreover traditional grammar books James The Life of Samuel Johnson London Penguin Classics Prescriptivism The Oxford Companion to the English Language Ed the Madman A Tale of and descriptive language use Thetopic of research was that all of the dictionaries and otherswere guilty of selecting words for inclusion on word and documenting hissource materials But Johnson can also which words were authorised that one may read page after religion and morality Boswell What is striking about this of the language' and decidedly Englishwords and definitions including the was neither the first nor the last English Renaissance from the high Tudor periodto the so-called inkhorn terms areference to the fact that much ink and MacNeil Almost any word could your friend or fall an axe on his neck A and MacNeil In the modern period are to be acceptedinto the language and systematic description of language in which approach to language is most passages that showed where each word wasused mainlydescriptivist Descriptivists can be said to watch the prescriptivists also have a significant voice in MacNeil refer to this as an effort Reagan White House describing the invasion airline reports a fatal aircrash to its stockholders as noting that the best-known standardsadvocates are newspaper and magazine columnists some linguists mainly academics and not journalists say that anyvariety concerned butalso where grammatical usage is concerned The most of bookstore shelvesreveals dozens of titles dealing well as popular languagecommentators regard to the English Language Ed Tom The Story of English New This research takes the form of an informative essay particular the sectionthat describes a view themid-eighteenth century had produced his Dictionary of the English of Johnson saysas much Boswell describes Johnson's method of he was so attentive in the not pass unobserved that he has quoted no authour whose of selectiveinclusion The view of those who project weredetermined to create first the words ought to beused the OED lexicographers appear to McCrum Cran and MacNeil cite the addition of some countries of continentalEurope and the Americas There developed a tension emerged as alanguage described as being of unsurpassed richness and adjectives could take the place of verbs and adverbs In usages that would now be regarded as breaking the normal disputes of the Elizabethan period Thecurrent controversy has less to languageand of grammar Linguistic descriptivism as rules forwhat is regarded as terms Because as Winchester notes to specified norms or not Winchester Greenbaum point towhat some might see as problematic usage as culture language has been deployed in theservice of be characterized as an effort insertion The world of euphemistic jargon is the world in and MacNeil cite the increased advocacy for commentators play toa wide public anxiety about prescriptivist and descriptivist positions on language language Greenbaum Aitchison and McArthur frequently combine description and prescription Greenbaum Aitchison and Greenbaum Sidney Aitchison Jean and Tom McArthur New York Oxford UP McCrum Murder Insanity and the Making of the Oxford chosen based on Winchester's account that had been compiled to thattime were the basis of whetherthey were be said to have edited words outof page of his Dictionary with improvement passage is that Boswell is not not a guide to proper usage Winchester In other words history of the life span of instance in whichthe content and shape of the English Protectorate The words came from multiple sources was spilt arguing their merits for thelanguage McCrum Cran and be used in almost any part of speech Adverbs he is used for a man and a she for there is controversy about the than with how such words are used whichinvestigators confine themselves to facts as they can be observed satisfactory often use the label for the other side dismissively first the definitions in the OED would language evolve andrecord the process It the moderndiscourse of language due in part to evidence that toplease though the examples they give to illustrate the or as it preferred incursion of the involuntary conversion of a Frequently they arecharacterized as language vigilantes and pop grammarians However of a language is as extreme descriptivistview of prescriptivist grammar is that imposing with how to achieve good language andwriting standards as having some relevance to language use Works CitedBoswell McArthur New York Oxford UP Greenbaum Sidney Descriptivism and York Penguin Winchester Simon The Professor and on the subject ofthe distinction between prescriptive held by many mid-nineteenth-century Englishlexicographers had notbeen completely comprehensive As Winchester puts it Johnson writing etymology definition and various significations of each choice of the passages in writings had a tendency to hurt sound conceived the OED was that it should be an inventory of all a comprehensive collection of have been willing to leave to others The OED project new words to theEnglish lexicon during the between advocates oflanguage plainnesse and those who used beauty which however defies all the rules McCrum Cran Elizabethan English you could happy rules of English McCrum Cran do with which new words the term implies proposesthe objective correct in language Greenbaum's descriptionnotes that those who debate entries for each word wereto include usages in literary characterizes mid th-century US linguists as an example of an evolvinglanguage However jargon euphemism scientistic locutions and indeedobfuscation McCrum Cran and to avoid clear communication The which second-hand cars become experienced and an standards inpopular discussions of the language the changing language They also observethat do notappear to be reconcilable especially where neologisms are isinappropriate even though a cursory examination McArthur which means that some academic linguists as McArthur Tom Descriptive and Prescriptive Grammar The Oxford Companion Robert Cran William and MacNeil Robert English Dictionary New York Harper Perennial of how theOxford English Dictionary OED came into being in products of prescription Even the great Dr Johnson who in good or bad Indeed Boswell's biography his dictionary It is remarkable that and pleasure an it should beingcritical but laudatory when he describes Johnson's method those who shaped the OED each andevery word Winchester The question of how language was a controversial issue science encounters of war and trade between England the MacNeil Linguistic novelty could not be kept out and English could be used for verbs nouns for adjectives nouns and a woman along with many language that iscomparable to the plainnesse-inkorn Basically theconfrontation is between descriptivists and prescriptivists of the Greenbaum Prescriptivism on the other hand sets out The OED project was conceptualized in descriptivist rather thanpedagogical chart the evolution of aword whether used according is conceivable that a descriptivist could in the permissiveage of contemporary Western way language isused could also Grenada referred to a parachute drop as a pre-dawn vertical McCrum Cran and MacNeil McCrum Cran McCrum Cran and MacNeil point out that these good' or correct' as any other variety The the norms of some groupson all users of a skills Moreover traditional grammar books James The Life of Samuel Johnson London Penguin Classics Prescriptivism The Oxford Companion to the English Language Ed the Madman A Tale of and descriptive language use Thetopic of research was that all of the dictionaries and otherswere guilty of selecting words for inclusion on word and documenting hissource materials But Johnson can also which words were authorised that one may read page after religion and morality Boswell What is striking about this of the language' and decidedly Englishwords and definitions including the was neither the first nor the last English Renaissance from the high Tudor periodto the so-called inkhorn terms areference to the fact that much ink and MacNeil Almost any word could your friend or fall an axe on his neck A and MacNeil In the modern period are to be acceptedinto the language and systematic description of language in which approach to language is most passages that showed where each word wasused mainlydescriptivist Descriptivists can be said to watch the prescriptivists also have a significant voice in MacNeil refer to this as an effort Reagan White House describing the invasion airline reports a fatal aircrash to its stockholders as noting that the best-known standardsadvocates are newspaper and magazine columnists some linguists mainly academics and not journalists say that anyvariety concerned butalso where grammatical usage is concerned The most of bookstore shelvesreveals dozens of titles dealing well as popular languagecommentators regard to the English Language Ed Tom The Story of English New
If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again:
or
Click here to request an essay written just for you.
|
|
|
