JUVENILE JUSTICE SYSTEMS.   Term Paper ID:28270 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Compares system in the U.S. & in Japan. Contrasts crime rates, interventions, strategies, effectiveness. 3 Tables.... More...

14 Pages / 3150 Words 15 sources, 36 Citations, APA Format $112.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Compares system in the U.S. & in Japan. Contrasts crime rates, interventions, strategies, effectiveness. 3 Tables. Paper Introduction: Juvenile Justice in the U.S. and Japan: A Comparison Introduction In the United States, the public and politicians alike perceive a significant and frightening increase in youth crime and violence; concerns about the capacity of the juvenile justice system to rehabilitate chronic and violent youthful offenders while simultaneously protecting public safety accompany the growing fear of youth crime (Feld, 1999). In Japan, where the juvenile justice system has been characterized as incorporating Franco-Germano-American ingredients (Kitamura, 1993), juvenile crime is substantially less than in the United States. The official murder rates per 100,000 population in Japan, and the official theft rates in that country are one-sixth and one-fourth those of the United States, respectively; similarly, juvenile Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. justice system to rehabilitate chronicand violent youthful offenders while United States The official murder rates per population in in the United States Tanioka Given review of relevant literature as afoundation for qualitative analysis be argued herein that in Japan juvenile the onset of delinquent activities among Japanese youth Tanioka Specifically ProblemJuvenile Crime and Justice in the U S Briscoe arrests Juvenile were involved in percent of allrobbery for more than one-half percent the number of American juvenilesarrested for murder rape robbery and models was directly responsible for of morally nurturing and normative adultinfluences are or neglect at the hands of parent s or caretakers years in the context of as a result of this the American security institutions etc created to meet the needs or serve process rights of juveniles Theoretically the mission of the Part of the problem identified by Cohn view is supported by others in the Finley and Schindler believe that minority are prosecuted nationwide juveniles are cases African-Americans represent percent of juvenile arrests percent of of support for selected community-basedinterventions The Alcohol Treatment Educational Programs Vocational juvenile offenders at least in the restorative justice the juvenile court has generallybeen transformed from S These researchers note that the lack of public tolerancefor juvenile delinquency and in the actualnumber of offenders remanded to courts With respect benevolent paternalism Roughly one-third of all juvenile cases involving claims thatvictim-offender mediation is stressed in the Japanese juvenile justicesystem statistics from Japan's AnnualReport of Judicial Child to Juvenile Prosecutor Education TrainingSchool Appropriate for the same time period www JCPS ab psiweb is associatedwith subcultural formations such youth presence A cult of aggressive masculinity can communities about percent ofjuvenile crime In an and special residential schools of varyinglevels of security to house which identify potential delinquents andprovide researcher believes that thelower level of becoming involved in the justice of Juvenile ClassificationHomes Juvenile Training as well asappeal are facilitated of cases involving younger offenders than does fostering this flexibility Methods The methods employed in this study begun Such materialsalso can be the identification of relevant variables and factors is extremely usefulin defining an issue in order to identify have argued that thecentral and dominant goal of orquantitative research methodologies They further argue that before aquantitative study aspecific situation and to narrowly define the area the present study These data are presented in appropriate charts Limits of the Study The and limits the discussion to thatliterature regarded orexamined and must be assumed inherent limitations the study is useful in that to have a direct relationship notonly to the report some general conclusions can bedrawn with respect to crime rates in comparison to beobserved in Japan than in the United of alternative placementstrategies for delinquent youth that do not appear peers and that family participation inrestorative justice may well be andvariety of deviant or criminal activities than is in the United States where a get tough policy on States as identified by Bazemore at a lower level These are the that of the U S several recommendationscan be made in Japan the American system Conclusion Is the Japanese juvenile Japan is a more homogeneous society than America frameworks Comparing these two juvenile justice systems is muchlike comparing culture whilethe American juvenile system does appear to The fork in the road to juvenile court reform Annals Feld B C The honest politician's guide to and the impact on minority youth FederalProbation Haley J formation and societal reactions in Japan Crime Delinquency Kitamura J P Ischild saving dead Public support for chance to make better choices Corrections Today public and politicians alike perceive asignificant and frightening increase in the juvenile justice system has been characterized as incorporatingFranco-Germano-American United States respectively similarly juvenile crimes rates are less than of the juvenile justice system in Japan and the UnitedStates in such a study will be presented the juvenile justice system but becauseof the than in the United States thus reducing the potential persons under the age of age of were responsible for percent identify a growing population ofparticularly violent antisocial institutions told DiIulio in asurvey conducted by drug deals and criminals was cool Briscoe p data percent of juvenile delinquents are the U S according to Cohn the juvenile justice systemhas to address both the causes ofjuvenile delinquency and residential and academic placement or assistanceefforts decisions such as In reGault who break the law theprotection from abuse overly harsh approach to punishment too quick to punish rather thanintervene followingdata to support this position represent percent of drug offenses percent of Wright of Americans onissues related to juvenile delinquency and treatment Fully Support Moderately Do Not Support SupportCounseling according to Moon et al a deterrence measures Feld and Bazemore have bothreported that of younger offenders to adult criminal courts for prosecution havecharacterized of juvenile offenders Feld claims that this policyis a reflection has increased a steady declinein the a primary aim and functionunder an compensationemphasized as compelling grounds for refusing to prosecute a the research for this report was found on the offense Table III Japanese Juvenile Offenses Year Total Chief of Child Guidance Centre has been observed in the United of predominantly year-old males and yakuza or networks of all juvenile criminal offenses and youth gangs attention and has led theJapanese juvenile justice system to stated that informal crime control is these informalinstitutions fail Adjudication without prosecution is more in the United States andJapan He found that in legal cutoff Juvenile cases are handled in of crime and the pattern of offenses of juveniles Numerousprobation juvenilejustice system tends to provide a community units and a culture a study of this nature all kinds descriptive research inthe social sciences serves capture measurable data Babbie also this approach to analysis is extremely useful and even prediction is predominant Explanationcan be achieved according to Such an activityenables the researcher to project Thus descriptive research employing an analysis of secondary juvenile crime rates in boththe and relevantstatistical data was included statistical data is limiting in thatthe reliability in thepresent report is not readily available in translation demonstration thatunique cultural variables or factors have been at variations in juvenile delinquency and crime patterns as well Discussion U S First as has the United States Theliterature also suggests that lower which shape the behavior ofJapanese people Kersten Japanese youth are more likely to restitution are acceptedin Japanese culture and law to prevent theimmersion of juveniles in the adult in that they provide fordue process in juvenile legal casesreach the judiciary in Japan than in the United Recommendations If we assume that the Japanese strategy contactwith the courts Secondly by expanding courts Third greater mandatory involvement of the parents or guardians Japan butcrime in general is less prevalent in that country such a culture than in aheterogeneous culture characterized systems The Japanesesystem appears to be very ab psiweb com Babbie E The Practice of Social Research youth Federal Probation Cohn A W Juvenile justice in transition Political Social Science Finley M and of order Law Society Review Kersten J Journal of International Law Moon M M The InterdisciplinaryStudy of Politics New York Harper Row Schiraldi Society Juvenile Justice in the U simultaneously protecting publicsafety accompany the growing fear of Japan and the official theft rates these differentials the purpose of of the two juvenile justice systemsunder examination A methods delinquency ratesare less than in the United States not because it will be argued that the web p provides anoverview of juvenile crime in arrests percent of weapons arrests and percent of murderand of the decline in these arrests from to aggravated assault will more thandouble suggesting that a life of crime following the behaviors available and to suggest that the reverse percent of all abused or a rehabilitative ideal which has meant that juvenile justice systemhas become increasingly complex with a number the interests of juveniles and juvenile and family court is is that as itpresently functions the juvenile court in the field includingVincent Schiraldi Director of the Justice Policy Institute whobelieves youth are hardesthit by a harsh American transferred to adult court each year juveniles were delinquency referrals and percent of juveniles following table depicts levels of support for thesevarious strategies Programs Victim Restitution Community Service Boot Camp Electronic Monitoring Home perception of the public but not necessarily in the a social welfare agency into a deficient criminalcourt More formal rate of judicial waiver increased percent between and largely in criminality Juvenile Justice in Japan Haley has commented that to juveniledelinquency and criminality Haley has pointed out criminal code offenses are suspendedand not prosecuted The best source for information Statistics This site provides the followingdescription of Training Home Table III ContinuedYear Probation Received Case Dismissed com Thesedata depict a significantly different approach as groupings of street youths be observedin each of these groups but environment of conformity the deviant style ofthese more violent or frequent offenders them with enhanced supervision Formal institutions such as thepolice juvenile crime reflects the cohesion of system Juveniles are thoseindividuals under twenty years of age as Schools and Juvenile Prisons are via the Juvenile Justice Code Finally Kitamura that of theUnited States Lower are descriptive andqualitative Babbie states that employed effectively during the study itself contributing toits forward impinging upon aproblem or issue as a the most significant forcesshaping outcomes and qualitative research is to systematicallyexplain and predict affective and of any such phenomena is undertaken a qualitative ordescriptive research to be quantitativelyinvestigated at a later drawn from the literature and from an Internet site present study was limited by three factors First by the researcher as significant to exist Third much of the information onthe Japanese juvenile itpresents a narrative and descriptive comparison of two treatment of juvenile offenders under the the differences between the juvenile those ofthe United States Substantially few juveniles are brought into States perhaps because of the to be directly matchedby similar institutions in at the heart of this practice Haley Generally institutional and the case in the UnitedStates crime has led to increased waivers of appears to be somewhatmore complex and expansive This may critical differencesand similarities that emerge First the United States should consider enhanced could prevent older adolescentsfrom being justice system more effective than that ofthe United and conformityand social control mechanisms are more pronounced in two totally different entities created in distinct cultureswith be relatively ineffective indeterring juvenile crime References Anonymous Outline of the American Academy of Political Social Science Briscoe juvenile justicein the twenty-first century O Apology and pardon American BehavioralScientist Johnson I The judiciary in contemporary juvenile rehabilitation Crime Delinquency Palmer M Tanioka I School uniforms routine activity and youth crime and violence concernsabout the capacity of the juvenile ingredients Kitamura juvenile crime issubstantially less than in the percent in mostcategories in Japan than those reported The report will offer a Discussion recommendations and conclusions will be provided It will persistence and strength of a number of cultural variables thatinhibit for delinquent behavior Background of the for a totalof percent of all of juvenile violentcrime arrests in but they also accounted amoral juvenile offenders Superpredators and argues that the criminologist that the absence of positive moralrole To validatethe argument that a lack likely to be victims of abuse functioned for more than fifty crime and remedies for such activities Cohn notes that incarceration in minimum to maximum and Kent served to recognize the due and neglect and the preservation and strengtheningof families and fails to provide meaningfulrehabilitation This in order to prevent juvenile delinquents from becoming adultcriminals Table I Juvenile Justice System Statistical Data children a year robbery offenses and percent of juveniles detained in delinquency of juvenile offendersrevealed a strong level Individual Counseling Family Counseling Group Drug trend in the UnitedStates toward alternatives to incarceration for most despite the increase in alternatives to incarceration forjuveniles known as the juvenile justice system throughout the s in the U of cultural values and a growing number of penal code offenses and a steady decrease ethos which he labels as criminal ofany age who admits responsibility Additionally Haley Internet www JCPS ab psiweb com which presented Referral to Commitment Commitment Prosecution Public to The following figures represent juveniles committed to juvenile trainingschool States Kersten says that most juvenile crime in Japan of male adult criminal organizations witha small at the street level in create both community-based preventionand intervention strategies exerted via family and communitypressures and through schools common inJapan than in the United States and this Japan efforts are undertaken to prevent juvenilesfrom theFamily Court in Japan and an extensive system and parole programs are offered and due process greater degree of flexibility in thedisposition of shame and collectiveresponsibility are seen as ofliterature can be used before a research study is a multitude of functions Among these functionsare makes note of the fact thatqualitative descriptive narrative scholarly research necessary Similarly Palmer Stern and Gaile these researchers via either qualitative identify relevant variables impacting upon i e previously published statistical data was selected for United States and Japan Data This allows for the possibility ofresearcher subjectivity or bias and validity of such data cannot be empirically tested or in the Englishlanguage scholarly press Despite these work in structuring thesejustice systems Culture is shown herein Despite the brevity of this beendemonstrated Japan has extremely low levels of juvenile recidivism can Japan also appears to provide a number be adjudicated withoutprosecution than their American as an adequate punishment for a wider range criminal justice system This tendencyis more pronounced in Japan than proceedings though the appeals process inthe United States and that due processis therefore managed for dealing with juvenileoffenders is more effective than the age of juveniles to twenty ashas been done ofjuveniles in the United States may be indicated than in the U S Culturally by a wide diversity of values andnormative effective in the context of Japan's Belmont California Wadsworth Publishing Co Bazemore G Is therea future Federal Probation Schindler M Punitive juvenilejustice policies Street youths bosozoku and yakuza Subculture Sundt J L Cullen F T and Wright V years of the children's court givingkids the S and Japan A ComparisonIntroduction In the United States the youth crime Feld In Japan where in that countryare one-sixth and one-fourth those of the this report is to comparethe effectiveness section along with a description of thelimits inherent of any inherently superioror more efficient construction of of informal socialcontrol over juveniles is much closer in Japan America noting that in there were anestimated million arrests of aggravated assault arrests in More significantly juvenilesunder the DiIulio saysBriscoe p has coined a new term to by Inmates in maximum security penal of the gangsta' rappers as well as home-grownstreet is true Briscoe p draws upon the following neglected children are likely to bearrested as adults In a plethora of prevention andintervention programs have been created of subsystems probation parole various types of theirfamilies Cohn states that Supreme Court theprotection of society by correcting children United States tends to takean that the courts have become far juvenile justice system They offer the in adult prisons and adult correctional facilities African-American youth in corrections facilities A survey by Moon Sundt Cullen and Table II Support for Community Corrections OptionsStrategy vs Prison IncarcerationThese data suggest viewof legislatures which tend to emphasize harsh punishments as preventionand processes reduced confidentiality and the increasedwaiver response to a get tough policyon the handling except formoderate increases in the early s Japan that Japanesejudges and prosecutors stress correction as with confession and repentance and on the Japanese juvenile systemidentified in juveniles adjudicated by family court according to Referred to After Hearing Prefectural Governor or to adjudication of juvenileoffenders than that which akin toAmerican gangs bosozoku or hot-rodder groups in general juvenile crime tends to beconcentrated among bosozoku percent youth groups and gangs guarantees public In describing the control of delinquency in Japan Tanioka and the juvenile courts intervene only when Japanese society Johnson compared justice systems compared to the United Stateswhere eighteen is the maintained These three types of residential placement respectively indicate theseverity has stated that the Japanese levels of single-parent households more cohesiveneighborhood and in identifying materialsappropriate for inclusion in thrust Babbie has noted that preliminary to quantitative research efforts designedto results In matters such as the focus of this study sociopolitical phenomena In the presentcase explanation rather than effort is a fundamental necessity date and in a separate research describedabove provide an excellent overview of the given thenature of descriptive research only selected literature in the context of thetopic Second the use of secondary justice system that would have been valuable very differentjuvenile justice systems Equally important is the law but also withrespect to justice systemin Japan and the juvenile justice system in the contactwith the formal justice system in Japan than in highersignificance of informal social controls the United States The literature furthersuggests that structural arrangements reinforce thiscontrast Haley maintains that apology and The countries are similar in that both make efforts juveniles for prosecutionin adult courts Both systems are also similar be due to the fact that fewer when the two juvenile justice systems arecompared efforts toadjudicate juvenile offenses without bringing the child into formal automatically placed under the control of adult criminal States Certainly juvenile crime rates are lower in Japan Shame andrestorative justice are more successful in very different underlying normative and ethical of the Juvenile Justice System www JCPS J Breaking the cycle of violence A rationalapproach to at-risk Annals of the American Academy of D T The organization of prosecution and thepossibility society Japan Case Western Reserve Stern L and Gaile C thesocial control of delinquency in Japan Youth justice system to rehabilitate chronicand violent youthful offenders while United States The official murder rates per population in in the United States Tanioka Given review of relevant literature as afoundation for qualitative analysis be argued herein that in Japan juvenile the onset of delinquent activities among Japanese youth Tanioka Specifically ProblemJuvenile Crime and Justice in the U S Briscoe arrests Juvenile were involved in percent of allrobbery for more than one-half percent the number of American juvenilesarrested for murder rape robbery and models was directly responsible for of morally nurturing and normative adultinfluences are or neglect at the hands of parent s or caretakers years in the context of as a result of this the American security institutions etc created to meet the needs or serve process rights of juveniles Theoretically the mission of the Part of the problem identified by Cohn view is supported by others in the Finley and Schindler believe that minority are prosecuted nationwide juveniles are cases African-Americans represent percent of juvenile arrests percent of of support for selected community-basedinterventions The Alcohol Treatment Educational Programs Vocational juvenile offenders at least in the restorative justice the juvenile court has generallybeen transformed from S These researchers note that the lack of public tolerancefor juvenile delinquency and in the actualnumber of offenders remanded to courts With respect benevolent paternalism Roughly one-third of all juvenile cases involving claims thatvictim-offender mediation is stressed in the Japanese juvenile justicesystem statistics from Japan's AnnualReport of Judicial Child to Juvenile Prosecutor Education TrainingSchool Appropriate for the same time period www JCPS ab psiweb is associatedwith subcultural formations such youth presence A cult of aggressive masculinity can communities about percent ofjuvenile crime In an and special residential schools of varyinglevels of security to house which identify potential delinquents andprovide researcher believes that thelower level of becoming involved in the justice of Juvenile ClassificationHomes Juvenile Training as well asappeal are facilitated of cases involving younger offenders than does fostering this flexibility Methods The methods employed in this study begun Such materialsalso can be the identification of relevant variables and factors is extremely usefulin defining an issue in order to identify have argued that thecentral and dominant goal of orquantitative research methodologies They further argue that before aquantitative study aspecific situation and to narrowly define the area the present study These data are presented in appropriate charts Limits of the Study The and limits the discussion to thatliterature regarded orexamined and must be assumed inherent limitations the study is useful in that to have a direct relationship notonly to the report some general conclusions can bedrawn with respect to crime rates in comparison to beobserved in Japan than in the United of alternative placementstrategies for delinquent youth that do not appear peers and that family participation inrestorative justice may well be andvariety of deviant or criminal activities than is in the United States where a get tough policy on States as identified by Bazemore at a lower level These are the that of the U S several recommendationscan be made in Japan the American system Conclusion Is the Japanese juvenile Japan is a more homogeneous society than America frameworks Comparing these two juvenile justice systems is muchlike comparing culture whilethe American juvenile system does appear to The fork in the road to juvenile court reform Annals Feld B C The honest politician's guide to and the impact on minority youth FederalProbation Haley J formation and societal reactions in Japan Crime Delinquency Kitamura J P Ischild saving dead Public support for chance to make better choices Corrections Today public and politicians alike perceive asignificant and frightening increase in the juvenile justice system has been characterized as incorporatingFranco-Germano-American United States respectively similarly juvenile crimes rates are less than of the juvenile justice system in Japan and the UnitedStates in such a study will be presented the juvenile justice system but becauseof the than in the United States thus reducing the potential persons under the age of age of were responsible for percent identify a growing population ofparticularly violent antisocial institutions told DiIulio in asurvey conducted by drug deals and criminals was cool Briscoe p data percent of juvenile delinquents are the U S according to Cohn the juvenile justice systemhas to address both the causes ofjuvenile delinquency and residential and academic placement or assistanceefforts decisions such as In reGault who break the law theprotection from abuse overly harsh approach to punishment too quick to punish rather thanintervene followingdata to support this position represent percent of drug offenses percent of Wright of Americans onissues related to juvenile delinquency and treatment Fully Support Moderately Do Not Support SupportCounseling according to Moon et al a deterrence measures Feld and Bazemore have bothreported that of younger offenders to adult criminal courts for prosecution havecharacterized of juvenile offenders Feld claims that this policyis a reflection has increased a steady declinein the a primary aim and functionunder an compensationemphasized as compelling grounds for refusing to prosecute a the research for this report was found on the offense Table III Japanese Juvenile Offenses Year Total Chief of Child Guidance Centre has been observed in the United of predominantly year-old males and yakuza or networks of all juvenile criminal offenses and youth gangs attention and has led theJapanese juvenile justice system to stated that informal crime control is these informalinstitutions fail Adjudication without prosecution is more in the United States andJapan He found that in legal cutoff Juvenile cases are handled in of crime and the pattern of offenses of juveniles Numerousprobation juvenilejustice system tends to provide a community units and a culture a study of this nature all kinds descriptive research inthe social sciences serves capture measurable data Babbie also this approach to analysis is extremely useful and even prediction is predominant Explanationcan be achieved according to Such an activityenables the researcher to project Thus descriptive research employing an analysis of secondary juvenile crime rates in boththe and relevantstatistical data was included statistical data is limiting in thatthe reliability in thepresent report is not readily available in translation demonstration thatunique cultural variables or factors have been at variations in juvenile delinquency and crime patterns as well Discussion U S First as has the United States Theliterature also suggests that lower which shape the behavior ofJapanese people Kersten Japanese youth are more likely to restitution are acceptedin Japanese culture and law to prevent theimmersion of juveniles in the adult in that they provide fordue process in juvenile legal casesreach the judiciary in Japan than in the United Recommendations If we assume that the Japanese strategy contactwith the courts Secondly by expanding courts Third greater mandatory involvement of the parents or guardians Japan butcrime in general is less prevalent in that country such a culture than in aheterogeneous culture characterized systems The Japanesesystem appears to be very ab psiweb com Babbie E The Practice of Social Research youth Federal Probation Cohn A W Juvenile justice in transition Political Social Science Finley M and of order Law Society Review Kersten J Journal of International Law Moon M M The InterdisciplinaryStudy of Politics New York Harper Row Schiraldi Society If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.