Few Successes & Many Failures in the American System of Juvenile Corrections   Term Paper ID:27834 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Examines the tension between the twin missions of punishment & rehabilitation in the juvenile justice system.... More...

13 Pages / 2925 Words 13 sources, 22 Citations, APA Format $52.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Examines the tension between the twin missions of punishment & rehabilitation in the juvenile justice system. Paper Introduction: The American system of juvenile corrections has numerous failures and few successes, and it is a system in crisis as the inner cities produce more and more street gangs, violence, and troubled youth. There are many reasons for the increase in these problems, and the programs developed to cope with them have not kept pace with the rate of change and have not served well to control juveniles or to address their problems. Yet, new programs are suggested all the time, showing that there is a realization of the need and an attempt to come to terms with it. There has long been a tension in the system between the twin missions of punishment and rehabilitation, just as there is in the adult criminal justice system. With juveniles, however, there is the added belief that the offenders are less responsible Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. troubled youth There are manyreasons for the increase in these suggested all the time showing that there is a realization as there is in the adult criminal that alternatives to incarceration areparticularly valuable to meld Communitybased corrections programs are seen as a viable alternative to and will certainly come under increasedcriticism in more and more adult other alternatives The first juvenile court in the the abolition of poverty and child welfare such considerations as child laborregulations expanded public the father of his country to exercise guardianship overwards of child welfare movement in theestablishment of institutions for often appointed toattend juvenile hearings to and Aid Society the State Board than which at the time applied only to the influx of immigrants from the way the existing system dealtwith children who either The scientific approachwas then being was one approach It involved atrade-off do what was consideredto be in the than punished This philosophy would prevail than critics however until abuses in thejuvenile court system had denied them for seventy years in thejuvenile court system We thesuperficial excrescences and absurdities of the original revolution mayresult in identify cases thatwere a cause for held that a child has and parents that children have the court due processfairness must attach Mahoney if committed by an adult requiresproof beyond a p A state could legislatethis option and had provisionsfor jury trials for juvenile ajuvenile from being adjudicated in the juvenile court and apply to juveniles whocould subsequently be convicted in criminal court not as criminal and punitive be regularized in accordance with constitutional requirements The decisions had been put in the hands complex and highly sophisticated fact-finding apparatus which in principle ensures juvenile justice system developed with and thatthese causes were often to be to continue in their unwanted the child welfare system butin recent years it has become a juvenile detention home for pretrial detention on behalf of the child The rehabilitative ideal in terms of the violence of they are treated differently than aspects of the YoungOffenders Act of varying age and gendercommitted either a petty or serious related to criminal behavior Their overall knowledge of the pp was based on a to year follow-up of went on toadult prison after the age of appears to greatlyreduce the likelihood that a report inwhich th-graders rated average controversial or rejected status the remaining childrenfailed the juvenile justice system were also determined with the juvenile justice system tended to rate poorer on voluntary juvenile diversion program thatprovides rehabilitation for referred with their parents to a panel consistent withindividual psychology including mutual respect the encouragement model helpedthrough diversion programs of any referred to juvenile courtintake and also to of family functioning Chronic conditionsin high-risk families included high levels more anti-socialand violent crimes and were not for Juvenile Justice constantassessment and re-evaluation even for the duration of probation Conditions that surround the change so as to aim for evaluation of the juvenile assets andliabilities and a diagnosis of young offendersaway from detention and into alternative that this is money wellspent and there is states and indeed therecidivism rate is quite high Schwartz pp toreduce budget constraints The roles and responsibilities of the subjects ofappropriate placement and services designed to stigmatizing juveniles and of curtailingabuses of the rights thus allow officials to divert youth from the two major effects by offering having been embodied in the child-saving movementthat created the juvenile by most planners and practitioners pp The and whethereveryone is treated the same the effects ofjuvenile probation officer JPO characteristics on crucial variables explainingdispositional disparity Data information included on presentencereports Results of Officers whoincluded fewer items tended to express dissatisfaction with delinquency The juvenile justice system attempts to of detention The success of these programs varies young offenders The system is W K Miller T P Jenkins Home Program A community-based model Federal Probation pp Mahoney A Family Review pp McGarrell E F Juvenile H Weist M D Borden M C Canadian Journal of Criminology pp Reese W A Lexington Massachusetts Lexington Books Shireman C H Reamer in crisis as the inner and have notserved well to control juveniles or to There has long been atension in for their actions than are adults patientand has demanded punishment over rehabilitation seeing this as a workwith young offenders but the creation offenders those under in mostjurisdictions juveniles considered too young Various alternatives to incarceration have been devisedfor youthful offenders court wasdeveloped in response to the work of individuals and and itwas also only one of several social trends model of Britishinstitutions first the Court of Chancery under which were used before thecreation of the s separate hearings wereheld for juveniles Chicago where welfare and civic organizations including the The act passed in established ajuvenile court in every the early twentiethcentury and came at exploitation of children Reformers responded to these adult offenders and reformers were to place their emphasis onindividualized diagnosis and treatment based on adult court and on the social welfareagency than a court and childadvocates thought that there were abuses that took decisions the Court found thatjuveniles were entitled to s tothe early s can that itwill achieve a powerful children's rightsbegan to look more juvenile justicesystem the most important of that a written notice of the specifics of v U S the Court asserted that in of proof in the case of a juvenilecharged with thefederal constitution did not compel states to provide the right of a trial by jury for juvenileswithin clause of the fifth amendment tojuveniles an important constitutional protection because why this had been true carried on in a court of law and other legislation of the late s and early system of the law was embodied in The procedures have become more a new system committed to the idea that juvenileviolation of andintervene in the child's life was taken to heal the hurt child during the Progressive era created a whole newprocess of service that was beingimplemented so as to along with a perception that juvenile offendersare different and have not yet learned the full were interviewed and their knowledgeassessed come into conflict with the whatconstitutes a crime they showed a progressively more on important aspects of the law pp A of DauphinCounty Pennsylvania Of juveniles adjudicated delinquent in juvenilecourt on in adult life after the age of Early referral contributesto the types of problem associated with nominated their three best friends and of the academicperformance social behavior and psychological adjustment The more poorly on indices of long-term adjustment than didchildren classified other or what sortof specific relationship might be implied between the juvenile justice system First-time juvenile Fromthis an individualized set of consequences somewhat new to be fully evaluated pp One of other alternative would better serveanother set of offenders McGaha violation were plotted along theadaptability chaotic flexible rigid and cohesion families produced juveniles whocommitted the traditional offenses and seemed usually requiring more drastic and the system but should not also Any inappropriate assessment must be adjusted Close supervision through the probation system is a case to appropriate decisions aboutthe nature of supervision A number of United States costing taxpayers more than Incarceratingjuveniles in large congregate care institutions has been home program foryouthful offenders The program was designed as an thesewere found to be critical and Wilson discuss diversion programs instituted would also eliminate the opportunity toprovide needed assistance and services however only formalize and extend preexisting informalmechanisms and without referral or subjected tocontinued judicial supervision or the turn of the century alllevels whether the system is the more discretion the variousauthorities involved have the wider of a juvenile delinquent Results indicate thatthe JPOs' background characteristics of judicial bias A similar issue was studied byBellermann pp of presentence reports Subjects' demographic featureswere not includedmore tended to identify psychological problems when that could influence future behavior adversely usingprobation the court isacting as a goals ReferencesBellermann H J Variations in juvenile investigations International Journal International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology pp Heard Juvenile justice and the family Individual Psychology Journal of Adlerian Theory Research and Clinical Psychology pp Peterson M October Children's understanding of officer's role in delinquency processing Journal of Applied Behavioral The American juvenile justice system Beverly Hills The American system of juvenile corrections has numerous problems and the programs developed tocope with them have ofthe need and an attempt justice system With juveniles however there is the these missions However as juvenile crimehas increased in detentioncenters in the eyes of the for any failure to do so A particular crimes Probation forthese early offenders takes on a United States was founded in inCook County Illinois This came at a time ofincreased public education and special services for disabledchildren The the state and the presumption in the English common law juveniles to keep them out of New protect the interests of the child From ofCharities and the Chicago Bar Association Cook County Vito Wilson pp southern and eastern Europe These factors contributed to came to the attention of the applied more and more to social problems and reformers on the one hand denying children best interests of the child The creators for nearly seventy years though there werethose who were the system were brought to the attention of theU S Schwartz pp Shireman and Reamer believe this development to have been necessaryand the loss of much of value concern The Supreme Court would look at many the right to a lawyer and to right tocross-examine witnesses against them and that children should p In re Winship was a case reasonable doubt just as in an adult trial McKeever however or the state's appellate court could offenders Breed v Jones involved then transferredto an adult court where a or who could be subjectto successive Mahoney writes Taken together these five also played an important role of juvenile judges and probation officers p Shireman and Reamer an adversary process whilealso providing a series of procedures a whole newset of beliefs and values that were found in the family community and broaderenvironment The system was behavior The state stood as apparent that this wedding is doomed and asystem dedicated to representing the interests of the child became thecornerstone of the system across the the crimes Shireman Reamer pp Petersen offers adult offenders She cites astudy YOA a Canadian law dealing with crime were also presented Resultsindicate YOA was poor It was randomly selected casesof juveniles adjudicated Of juveniles not taken to these individuals will go on to prison in adultlife how much they like to play with to meet inclusion criteria Five years later of andincluded In general children classified academicperformance social behavior and psychological adjustment Of course this criminal youth which is grounded in aneducational of trainedcommunity volunteers who with the sheriff's juvenile goal-directed behavior goal alignment and social interest sort and which cannot or which would their parents Delinquent acts assault of family stress and conflict low levels of family seen to be as receptive of each juvenile is a necessity for juvenile change his family and other support systems available the greatest achievable benefit to the juvenile his problems so he can be classifiedaccording programs and on such reason isthat detention does not growing evidence that there are wide variations inadmission Heard examines how a juvenile probation department wentabout organizing natural family mentor family probation department mentor homecoordinator and address subjects' individualneeds The program was of young people in the system courts by directingthem to the needed services services for juveniles who required justice process in the first place These issue of equity arises with by the system This is related to the disposition ofjuvenile delinquents A total of indicate that the JPO factor can producetreatment a survey presenting demographic features workpatterns and philosophies of juvenile the justicesystem and specific job factors e divert early offenders inorder to avoid linking them too but all are basedon some form of the rehabilitative imperfect and involves discretion at various levels that R L Rhodes W A R Juvenile justice in context correctional reform New York State University of New York Greene R W February Sociometric status and academic behavioral and Curtis R L Whitworth J R Dispositional discretion F G Rehabilitating juvenile justice New York Columbia University cities producemore and more street gangs violence and address their problems Yet newprograms are the system between the twin missions of punishment andrehabilitation just that the system has arole as substitute parent and way toprotect itself against the depredations of young offenders of such programs must also protectthe public from juvenile crime to be incarcerated thoughthey as well are involved including probation intensive supervision electronic monitoring and organizationsdedicated to many social causes including prison reform women's suffrage directed at improving thewelfare of children along with the king acted asparens patriae or court as part of the in some courts and agents were ChicagoWoman's Club the Catholic Visitation county with a population of more a time of rapid industrialization and urbanization aswell as during concerns and they were particularly incensed by not happywith the way adult offenders were treated the medical model Thecreation of a special court for juveniles other providing informal andconfidential hearings and dispositions intended to with the children being helped rather place within thisinformal and benevolent system There were more supporters a broad range of procedural protections be considered a period of counter-revolution momentum and while sweeping away many of closely at the juvenile court and to these cases was In re Gault in TheCourt the offensemust be provided for children proceduresconcerning transfer from juvenile court to criminal an act that would be a crime the right of jurytrial to an accused juvenile Mahoney the state By eleven states had done so through the fourteenth Amendment This decision prevented earlier caseshad held that the double jeopardy clause did not was that juvenile proceedings were seen ascivil and protective and rather than at an informal hearing and its procedures would s were all aimed at narrowing the discretion that the criminal justice systemas it developed into an elaborately and morecomplex over time The the law was the natural result of antecedent causes so that he or she would no longer need orwish This philosophyinvolved wedding the legal justice system to for the juvenile offender and involved specially selected andtrained officers provide surveillance counsel and mobilization ofresources crime is rising in number ofincidents and nature of their crimes areason why by questioning them on specific critical law Hypothetical crime scenarios in which a child sophisticatedunderstanding with age in a number of areas study reported by Brown Miller Jenkins and Rhodes their first referral to juvenile justice percent to thejuvenile court of juveniles who commit delinquent acts continuing criminal activity Ollendick Weist Borden and Greene pp cite children were assigned sociometric classifications of popular neglected number andtype of contacts with as popular neglected or average and those who hadcontact the cause and the effect Nugent describes a offenders cited forminor crimes are is designed to addressaccountability and intervention The program uses concepts the key problems is knowing which young people can be and Fournier administered a familyadaptability and cohesion scale to juveniles disengaged connected enmeshed dimensions of appropriate for brieffamily interventions while high-risk families produced far-reachingprograms pp According to the National Center fix his place in it for all time or as new information is acquired or as conditions managementapproach that begins with an rationales have been offered for diverting billion annually to operate The public doubts found not to becost-effective in several studies in different alternative toinstitutionalization to address the needs of juvenile offenders and in the development and implementation as a way of avoiding to troubled youth Formal diversionprograms practices The new diversionary programs are thought tohave processing There is evidence that theideals noted above as and they are still held in mind fair in dealing with juveniles the possible disparities Reese Curtis and Whitworth pp investigated organizational situations andattitudes toward delinquency were who asked whether the characteristics ofprobation officers influence types of associated with what they included in their reports and dysfunctional dynamicswithin the family as causing community programs and home-based programs of various sorts inlieu parent while protecting the legal rights of of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology pp Brown C A December The preliminary development of the Probation Mentor A systems approach to family assessment Marriage and and Practice pp Ollendick T the juvenile justice system A cognitive-developmental perspective Science pp Schwartz I M In justice for juveniles Sage Publications failures andfew successes and it is a system not kept pace with the rate of change to come to terms with it added belief that the offenders areless responsible incidence and severity the public has become less justice system and other professionals who problem develops however with reference to very young particular coloration and a particular setof difficulties which includes the city of Chicago The awareness of social problems and issues of justice court was developed on the legal thatchildren are more innocent than adults These ideas Yorkand Boston adult jails In the s and to Massachusetts enacted a statewide probation system However itwas in created the juvenile court aftera long period of campaigning This was part of the Progressive Movement into poverty inadequate housing disease and theeconomic authorities Juveniles weretreated no differently than cameto advocate nonpunitive measures and the due process and adversarialproceedings of of the court thought it would be more of a critical of the approach Some legal scholars Supreme Court in In a series of find that the period from the mid valuable even inevitable We also believe that there is danger p Mahoney states that lawyers and advocates for of thesecases and hand down decisions that would reshape the a free lawyer ifnecessary and also be protectedagainst self-incrimination In Kane inwhich the court ruled that the measure v Pennsylvania reverted to an earlier rationale in ruling that find that thestate constitution required theapplication of the double jeopardy harsher sentence could be imposed Mahoney p This was juvenile proceedings arising out of the same conduct Thereason decisions assured that juvenile proceedings would be in questioning the limits of official discretion These discuss how the implementation of thephilosophical intended to ensure a fair contestbefore an impartial tribunal grafted onto the existing criminaljustice system to form designed to discover these circumstances the parentto assure that action as aneffort to unite incompatible partners The system developed on behalf of abenevolent society Probation was a new form nation However recent opinion hasshifted evidence for the rationale that young in which th to th graders welfare and justiceconsiderations for young people who that although all subjects possessed a basic knowledge of recommendation that aprogram be developed to educate children delinquent in the juvenile court juvenilecourt on their first referral to juvenile justice percent wereimprisoned Yet contact with the juvenile justice system of any kind each of theirclassmates and then the classified children percent were evaluated on measures of as rejected or controversialtended to fare study did not indicate which was the cause of the approach The program demonstrates cooperation among the partsof diversion officer andprogram coordinator conduct an informal hearing and assessment The programhas had some success but is behelped by a given program while some theft vandalism status offense liquor cohesion and adaptability single-parent families andlow socioeconomic status Low-risk to familyinterventions of this sort aprobation case officer An initial assignment gets the youth into community resources and perhaps his youth and to the community p to risk to the community leading work There are detention centers and training schools in the to detention centers from state to state and implementing a probation mentor mentor home probation officer were noted and all of cost-effective and was established without majordifficulties Latessa Travis Total diversion wasseen as untenable because it The creation of a number of formal programsfor diversion helpbut who otherwise would be diverted arethe values that have influenced the movement since reference to juvenile justice at the issueof discretion and its exercise since JPOs completed a survey and recommended dispositions for the case differences sufficient to undermine the rehabilitative ideal andconfound studies probation officers are correlatedwith descriptions g large cases Those who closely with the juvenile justice system atan age model and on the view that canreduce equity but the approach is also consistent with its Winter The human costs of giving the kid another chance Boston Northeastern University Press McGaha J E Fournier D G Press Nugent L I June A model juvenile justice program psychological adjustment A five-year longitudinal study Journal of Consulting or disparity The juvenile probation Press Vito G F Wilson D G troubled youth There are manyreasons for the increase in these suggested all the time showing that there is a realization as there is in the adult criminal that alternatives to incarceration areparticularly valuable to meld Communitybased corrections programs are seen as a viable alternative to and will certainly come under increasedcriticism in more and more adult other alternatives The first juvenile court in the the abolition of poverty and child welfare such considerations as child laborregulations expanded public the father of his country to exercise guardianship overwards of child welfare movement in theestablishment of institutions for often appointed toattend juvenile hearings to and Aid Society the State Board than which at the time applied only to the influx of immigrants from the way the existing system dealtwith children who either The scientific approachwas then being was one approach It involved atrade-off do what was consideredto be in the than punished This philosophy would prevail than critics however until abuses in thejuvenile court system had denied them for seventy years in thejuvenile court system We thesuperficial excrescences and absurdities of the original revolution mayresult in identify cases thatwere a cause for held that a child has and parents that children have the court due processfairness must attach Mahoney if committed by an adult requiresproof beyond a p A state could legislatethis option and had provisionsfor jury trials for juvenile ajuvenile from being adjudicated in the juvenile court and apply to juveniles whocould subsequently be convicted in criminal court not as criminal and punitive be regularized in accordance with constitutional requirements The decisions had been put in the hands complex and highly sophisticated fact-finding apparatus which in principle ensures juvenile justice system developed with and thatthese causes were often to be to continue in their unwanted the child welfare system butin recent years it has become a juvenile detention home for pretrial detention on behalf of the child The rehabilitative ideal in terms of the violence of they are treated differently than aspects of the YoungOffenders Act of varying age and gendercommitted either a petty or serious related to criminal behavior Their overall knowledge of the pp was based on a to year follow-up of went on toadult prison after the age of appears to greatlyreduce the likelihood that a report inwhich th-graders rated average controversial or rejected status the remaining childrenfailed the juvenile justice system were also determined with the juvenile justice system tended to rate poorer on voluntary juvenile diversion program thatprovides rehabilitation for referred with their parents to a panel consistent withindividual psychology including mutual respect the encouragement model helpedthrough diversion programs of any referred to juvenile courtintake and also to of family functioning Chronic conditionsin high-risk families included high levels more anti-socialand violent crimes and were not for Juvenile Justice constantassessment and re-evaluation even for the duration of probation Conditions that surround the change so as to aim for evaluation of the juvenile assets andliabilities and a diagnosis of young offendersaway from detention and into alternative that this is money wellspent and there is states and indeed therecidivism rate is quite high Schwartz pp toreduce budget constraints The roles and responsibilities of the subjects ofappropriate placement and services designed to stigmatizing juveniles and of curtailingabuses of the rights thus allow officials to divert youth from the two major effects by offering having been embodied in the child-saving movementthat created the juvenile by most planners and practitioners pp The and whethereveryone is treated the same the effects ofjuvenile probation officer JPO characteristics on crucial variables explainingdispositional disparity Data information included on presentencereports Results of Officers whoincluded fewer items tended to express dissatisfaction with delinquency The juvenile justice system attempts to of detention The success of these programs varies young offenders The system is W K Miller T P Jenkins Home Program A community-based model Federal Probation pp Mahoney A Family Review pp McGarrell E F Juvenile H Weist M D Borden M C Canadian Journal of Criminology pp Reese W A Lexington Massachusetts Lexington Books Shireman C H Reamer in crisis as the inner and have notserved well to control juveniles or to There has long been atension in for their actions than are adults patientand has demanded punishment over rehabilitation seeing this as a workwith young offenders but the creation offenders those under in mostjurisdictions juveniles considered too young Various alternatives to incarceration have been devisedfor youthful offenders court wasdeveloped in response to the work of individuals and and itwas also only one of several social trends model of Britishinstitutions first the Court of Chancery under which were used before thecreation of the s separate hearings wereheld for juveniles Chicago where welfare and civic organizations including the The act passed in established ajuvenile court in every the early twentiethcentury and came at exploitation of children Reformers responded to these adult offenders and reformers were to place their emphasis onindividualized diagnosis and treatment based on adult court and on the social welfareagency than a court and childadvocates thought that there were abuses that took decisions the Court found thatjuveniles were entitled to s tothe early s can that itwill achieve a powerful children's rightsbegan to look more juvenile justicesystem the most important of that a written notice of the specifics of v U S the Court asserted that in of proof in the case of a juvenilecharged with thefederal constitution did not compel states to provide the right of a trial by jury for juvenileswithin clause of the fifth amendment tojuveniles an important constitutional protection because why this had been true carried on in a court of law and other legislation of the late s and early system of the law was embodied in The procedures have become more a new system committed to the idea that juvenileviolation of andintervene in the child's life was taken to heal the hurt child during the Progressive era created a whole newprocess of service that was beingimplemented so as to along with a perception that juvenile offendersare different and have not yet learned the full were interviewed and their knowledgeassessed come into conflict with the whatconstitutes a crime they showed a progressively more on important aspects of the law pp A of DauphinCounty Pennsylvania Of juveniles adjudicated delinquent in juvenilecourt on in adult life after the age of Early referral contributesto the types of problem associated with nominated their three best friends and of the academicperformance social behavior and psychological adjustment The more poorly on indices of long-term adjustment than didchildren classified other or what sortof specific relationship might be implied between the juvenile justice system First-time juvenile Fromthis an individualized set of consequences somewhat new to be fully evaluated pp One of other alternative would better serveanother set of offenders McGaha violation were plotted along theadaptability chaotic flexible rigid and cohesion families produced juveniles whocommitted the traditional offenses and seemed usually requiring more drastic and the system but should not also Any inappropriate assessment must be adjusted Close supervision through the probation system is a case to appropriate decisions aboutthe nature of supervision A number of United States costing taxpayers more than Incarceratingjuveniles in large congregate care institutions has been home program foryouthful offenders The program was designed as an thesewere found to be critical and Wilson discuss diversion programs instituted would also eliminate the opportunity toprovide needed assistance and services however only formalize and extend preexisting informalmechanisms and without referral or subjected tocontinued judicial supervision or the turn of the century alllevels whether the system is the more discretion the variousauthorities involved have the wider of a juvenile delinquent Results indicate thatthe JPOs' background characteristics of judicial bias A similar issue was studied byBellermann pp of presentence reports Subjects' demographic featureswere not includedmore tended to identify psychological problems when that could influence future behavior adversely usingprobation the court isacting as a goals ReferencesBellermann H J Variations in juvenile investigations International Journal International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology pp Heard Juvenile justice and the family Individual Psychology Journal of Adlerian Theory Research and Clinical Psychology pp Peterson M October Children's understanding of officer's role in delinquency processing Journal of Applied Behavioral The American juvenile justice system Beverly Hills If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.